Preliminary Ecological Appraisal (PEA)
A Preliminary Ecological Appraisal (PEA) is the term used to describe an initial assessment of the ecological features present, and species potentially present within a site and its surrounding area. A PEA will be required for validation purposes in the situations listed in Figure 1 which can be found in the 'What information and surveys are required for an application to be valid?' section above.
A PEA comprises of a desk study and a habitat survey, followed by a written assessment.
Objectives of a PEA:
- Identify the likely ecological constraints associated with a project taking into account the projects extent and nature
- Identify any mitigation measures likely to be required, taking into account the ‘Mitigation Hierarchy’ and ‘Step-Wise Approach’
- Identify opportunities to deliver ecological enhancements on-site at an early stage of the development process, maximising biodiversity benefits within the site and minimising the need for off-site compensation, which should only be considered as a last resort.
- Identify any additional ecological surveys that may be required
Contents of a PEA:
In most cases, it is expected that a PEA would include:
- Identification of any designated nature conservation sites (statutory and non-statutory) that could be affected by the project.
- Mapping of the habitat types present to provide a visual representation of the land within and adjacent to the site boundaries.
- Assessment of the likely importance of the habitats present, determining (as far as possible within the constraints of the site visit(s) undertaken) whether there are any protected or priority habitats present, which could be affected by the project. Any limitations in relation to this must be clearly stated.
- Assessment of the likely presence of protected and priority species, which could be affected by the proposed development, and confirmation of the presence or absence of any such species, as far as possible within the constraints of the site visit(s) and the time of the year they were undertaken.
- Identification of any ecological constraints to the client and relevant members of the project team (Based on information gathered in bullets 1-4). This will allow likely significant effects to be avoided wherever possible through careful scheme design and ensure that the likely requirements for possible mitigation and licensing are understood (based upon the level of information known about the project at the time of the assessment).
- A list of further ecological surveys likely to be required to inform a proposal, together with their appropriate scope, methodology and timing (Based on information gathered in bullets 1-5)
- Identification of opportunities for ecological enhancement or Net Biodiversity Benefit.
Desk study or background data search
A desk study or background data search should be the first step when carrying out a PEA and, where necessary, should include a data search from the local record centre for North Wales, Cofnod.
Cofnod is the only organisation providing information on Local Wildlife Sites (LWS) and will ensure consultants consider all species that could be potentially present.
Data Map Wales can be consulted for certain data sets including Statutory Protected Sites and Ancient Woodland.
Please note: Reports using data from The National Biodiversity Network (NBN) will not be accepted because they are not for commercial use.
MAGIC mapping does not include licensing, Local Wildlife Site information or other habitat information for Wales because it relates to England only.
Habitat Survey
Where relevant, the habitat survey within a PEA should include the following:
- A plan of the habitat types present using a published and recognised habitat classification.
- An assessment of the likely presence of protected or priority species, and where relevant, an assessment of the likely importance of the habitat features affected by the proposed development for such species, with reference to available desk study information. This should include:
- Plants
- Fungi
- Terrestrial and aquatic invertebrates
- Fish (where relevant, based on an assessment of any watercourses and water bodies present);
- Amphibians (including both breeding and terrestrial habitat)
- Reptiles
- Breeding, wintering and migratory birds
- Bats (including potential roost sites, and foraging and commuting habitats/features)
- Other protected or priority mammal species, as relevant
- Mapping of any stands of non-native invasive plant species.
- Recording of any incidental sightings of priority or protected species, or field signs of such species.
- Recommended measures to provide a Net Benefit for Biodiversity.
Protected Species Surveys
Bats
Bat surveys must be completed in accordance with the following national guidance.
Bat Surveys for Professional Ecologists: Good Practice Guidelines 4th edition - Guidance for professionals - Bat Conservation Trust.
If a bat survey demonstrates that bats and/or a known roost are likely to be affected by the proposed development and planning permission is to be granted, full information will be required prior to any decision, including complete details of mitigation, monitoring, long-term maintenance plans and compliance. The level of detail in the submission should be similar to that required in a European Protected Species Licence (EPSL). The LPA will place conditions and an informative on any application and it is the responsibility of the applicant to have an EPSL before work commences. Criminal proceedings may take place if the EPSL is not applied for and complied with in full.
If a PEA concludes that development is likely to affect bat foraging and/or commuting habitat, linear features such as tree lines should be retained, and compensatory planting should be considered wherever possible. This should be reflected in the Green Infrastructure Statement. Conditions regarding bat friendly lighting will be imposed on any permission.
Lighting and Bats
Lighting submissions should be compliant with The Institution of Lighting Professionals (ILP) latest practical guidance on considering the impact upon bats when designing lighting schemes in August 2023: Bats and Artificial Lighting in the UK' Guidance Note GN 08 / 23
Any conditions referring to a bat friendly lighting scheme should be accompanied by a lighting contour plan. That is a horizontal illuminance contour plan which is prepared by a suitably experienced and competent lighting professional (Member of the Institution of Lighting Professionals (ILP), Chartered Institution of Building Services Engineers (CIBSE), Society of Light and Lighting (SLL) or similar to ensure competency) using an appropriate software package to model ‘Day 1’, extent of light spill from the proposed, retained and, possibly, existing luminaires. The various buffer zone widths and illuminance limits which have been agreed with the ecologist can then be overlaid to determine if any further mitigation is necessary.
Great Crested Newts
North East Wales is a stronghold for Great Crested Newt (GCN). The species relies on both aquatic and terrestrial habitat for breeding, foraging and commuting. They are found in the borough over a wide variety of habitats.
Where development is within 300m of suitable aquatic habitat presence or absence surveys may be required. This should be determined in the conclusions of the PEA.
Until further up-to-date guidance is released, The Great Crested Newt Mitigation Guidelines (2001) and The Great Crested Newt Conservation Handbook should be used as references. The Supplementary Planning Guidance provides some specific mitigation requirements for sites around the Deeside and Buckley Newt Sites and Halkyn Mountain Special Areas of Conservation.
Habitat Suitability Index (HSI)
HSI is a rapid assessment tool and shown to be ineffective at determining GCN presence within Flintshire County Council. Poor HSI scores will not necessarily mean GCN are absent from a site.
eDNA
Use of eDNA is just another survey technique, it is not a mandatory requirement. We will accept this technique to determine GCN presence or absence if samples are undertaken in strict accordance with the published technical advice note and they are collected by a suitably trained and experienced licensed GCN surveyor. Samples can be taken from 15th April to 30th June.
- This technique will not provide population size class assessments.
- Should a population size class assessment be required for the proposed development/project then the applicant will require 6 survey visits using conventional survey methods, in accordance with current recommendations within the Great Crested Newt Mitigation Guidelines, (2001).
Otter
Where applications affect or are within close proximity to a watercourse an otter survey may be required. This will be determined by the PEA.
Dormouse
There are small pockets of dormouse recorded in Flintshire. The requirement to carry out a presence or absence survey is dependent upon the presence of historical records and the nature of the application. This will be determined by the PEA.
Badger
Badgers are common in the county, they can be found across all habitats and can move quickly onto sites if the habitat and feeding opportunities are available. It is common for pre-commencement checks to form part of a planning condition. For the benefit of developer, these should be carried out by a qualified ecologist and as close to commencement as possible.
Reptiles
There are five species of reptile found in Flintshire, across habitats such as grassland, open mosaic, scrub, heathland and wetland. They are particularly prevalent on brownfield sites and quarries. Due to the restricted survey period and weather dependency, planning surveys in advance is essential. This will be determined by the PEA.
Survey Timings
For certain species and habitats, surveys can be carried out at any time of year, but for other species, particular times of year are required to give the most reliable results, as indicated in Figure 4.
- Surveys conducted outside of optimal times below may be unreliable. For certain species (e.g. Great Crested Newt) surveys over the winter period are unlikely to yield any useful information. Similarly negative results gained outside the optimal period should not be interpreted as absence of a species and further survey work maybe required during the optimal survey season. This is especially important where existing surveys and records show the species has been found previously on site or in the surrounding area. An application may not be valid until survey information is gathered from an optimum time of year.
- Species surveys are also very weather dependent so it may be necessary to delay a survey or to carry out more than one survey if the weather is not suitable, E.g. heavy rain is not good for surveying for otters, as it washes away their spraint (droppings). Likewise bat surveys carried out in wet or cold weather may not yield accurate results.
- Absence of evidence of a species does not necessarily mean that the species is not there, nor that its habitat is not protected (e.g. a bat roost is protected whether any bats are present or not).
- Local Biological / Environmental Records Centre may have useful existing information and records.
Figure 4 - Ecological Survey Seasons
Figure 4 shows a calendar of survey timings for different species and habitats
Calendar of survey timings for different species and habitats.